(Spoiler alert: You can, but make sure you do it right). In a real South Dakota case involving a prenuptial agreement where a wife waived her rights to her husband’s estate upon his death, the court ruled in favor of the wife, declaring the agreement invalid. The court determined that the wife had not entered into the agreement voluntarily due to several factors:
– A significant power imbalance between the wealthy husband and the wife with limited education,
– The surprising nature of the presentation of the agreement (he drove her to his attorney’s office without telling her),
– The wife’s credible testimony of not understanding the agreement, the lack of prior discussion about the prenup, and
– The absence of independent legal counsel for the wife.
Despite this ruling, it’s important to note that waiving rights to a spouse’s estate in a prenuptial agreement is permitted under S.D. Codified Laws § 29A-2-213, as long as both parties enter into it voluntarily and it’s not unconscionable. This case serves as a reminder of the importance of ensuring that prenuptial agreements are entered into with full understanding and without undue pressure.
Connolly v. Connolly, 270 NW 2d 44 (1978)